| Year |
Ki-Shy Cup Champion |
Runner-Up |
Points Winner |
Fridge |
| 2000 |
DC Doomsday* |
FC Delight |
NA |
KDaddy Krusaders |
| 2001 |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
DC Doomsday |
NA |
KDaddy Krusaders |
| 2002 |
The Best Team in the World |
DC Doomsday |
NA |
KDaddy Krusaders
|
| 2003 |
Swordfish Captains |
The Best Team in the World |
The Best Team in the World |
KDaddy Krusaders |
| 2004 |
Springfield Schreindoggs |
Dead Rabbits |
The Yorktown Posse |
Swordfish Captains |
| 2005 |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
McGang Green |
McGang Green |
Kadday Krusaders |
| 2006 |
Swordfish Captains |
Dead Rabbits |
Swordfish Captains |
KDaddy Krusaders |
| 2007 |
McGang Green |
Mike Matthews |
DC Doomsday |
Swordfish Captains |
| 2008 |
VIP Crew |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
VIP Crew |
KDaddy Krusaders |
| 2009 |
The Broadstreet Brotherhood |
KDaddy Krusaders |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
Shimmy Shimmy Cocoa Puffs |
| 2010 |
Swordfish Captains |
Dead Rabbits |
McGang Green |
VIP Crew |
| 2011 |
BT Showtime |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
Renaissance Men |
| 2012 |
The Tornados |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
Swordfish Captains |
Shimmy Shimmy Cocoa Puffs |
| 2013 |
The Tornados |
Shimmy Shimmy Cocoa Puffs |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
Dead Rabbits |
| 2014 |
The Tornados |
Arlignton Schreindoggs |
The Tornados |
Shimmy Shimmy Cocoa Puffs |
| 2015 |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
Dead Rabbits |
McGang Green |
KDaddy Krusaders |
| 2016 |
FC Delight |
Lichtenstein Brawlers |
Swordfish Captains |
BT Showtime |